We found this question interesting and important for class 10 students. We have presented 3 sample answers to provide a variety of choices for students. comment below if it helped you.
Lesson: A Triumph of Surgery
Class 10 CBSE
Textbook: Footprints without Feet
Question Source: CBSE Sample Paper 2023-24
The story, A Triumph of Surgery is a powerful example of the importance of saying “no”. Explain.
Sample Answer 1 (40-50 words)
The story highlights the importance of making responsible choices and saying “no” to unhealthy practices, even if it means going against the desires of loved ones. Dr Herriot advised Mrs Pumphrey to stop overfeeding Tricki and give it a balanced diet and exercise. However, she could not say ‘No’ to stuffing and pampering her dog which resulted In making it sluggish and seriously ill.
Sample Answer 2 (100-120 words)
Certainly! “A Triumph of Surgery” is a powerful example of the significance of saying “no” in situations where one’s values or integrity are at risk. The story’s protagonist, Tricki the dog, becomes overweight due to Mrs Pumphrey’s indulgence and overfeeding. Dr Herriot advises her to stop indulging Tricki and to provide him with a balanced diet and exercise instead. But, Mrs Pumphrey does not listen to him.
The story highlights the importance of making responsible choices and saying “no” to unhealthy practices, even if it means going against the desires of loved ones. Dr Herriot’s advice emphasizes the significance of putting the well-being of pets above their owners’ desire to spoil them. The story also highlights the importance of responsible pet ownership and the bond between pets and their owners.
In summary, “A Triumph of Surgery” is a powerful example of the importance of saying “no” to unhealthy practices and making responsible choices. Not stopping at the right moment can be disastrous.
Short Story – Importance of Saying NO
Sample Answer 3 (100-120 words)
In the story “A Triumph of Surgery,” Mrs Pumphrey is shown to be a doting and indulgent owner who spoils Tricki the dog with rich food and treats, leading to his excessive weight gain and poor health. Mrs Pumphrey’s failure to understand the importance of saying “no” to overfeeding and indulging Tricki leads to his poor health and the need for medical intervention.
The story highlights the negative consequences of indulgence and the importance of stopping at the right moment. Dr Herriot advises Mrs Pumphrey to stop indulging Tricki and to provide him with a balanced diet and exercise to promote his health. Through Dr Herriot’s intervention and Mrs Pumphrey’s willingness to listen and change her ways, Tricki is able to regain his health and well-being.
In conclusion, “A Triumph of Surgery” teaches us the importance of saying “no” to unhealthy practices and indulgence, and the significance of making responsible choices that promote the health and well-being of our pets. Mrs Pumphrey’s initial failure to understand this lesson highlights the need for us to be mindful of our choices and to stop at the right moment to avoid negative consequences.